I don’t know if it was worthwhile to worry about Morgan’s
future on TGD as season 3 progressed, but I did so anyway.
It was a completely different kind of worry than I felt when
Glassman was battling cancer. The difference is that word “battle”—unless an
actor is getting ready to part ways with a show (or vice versa), there are
plenty of ways for the character to triumph and carry on with their life, and
career, as they choose.
But rheumatoid arthritis? For a young surgeon? There’s no
real “battle” to be had; in Morgan’s case, there certainly wasn’t once she
decided to put her own hands under the knife despite Glassman’s objections. One
synovectomy, one earthquake, and one desperate need to help later, Dr. Morgan
Reznik’s “Plan A” was over. As in… really over. Dr. Andrews confirmed it
back in March.
I’d worried about her future as S3 progressed because, surprise surprise, I couldn’t tell where they were going with the story. Was it going to become something about Morgan developing a dependence on painkillers? About an ever-building web of lies to protect her secret? Was her hand going to fumble so badly while leading an operation that she’d become liable for permanently disabling a patient—or worse?
But just as Shaun and Lea have their catapult moments (as I
call them) here and there, so do others at St. Bonaventure. In fact, Morgan had
something very similar in the “Heartbreak” episode: once when she announced to
Lim that she’d just performed her last surgery, and again when she changed her
mind about the synovectomy that might allow her to be a card-carrying surgeon a
little longer.
So by the “Hurt” episode that followed, all my guesses about
Morgan’s future were fast flying out the window. And when she unbandaged her
own hands near the end of that episode (and probably threw those out the window
too), I was stumped and almost wondered if Fiona Gubelmann was leaving the
show.
I shouldn’t have been so stumped, though, as changes in jobs
and/or job titles had already happened to most TGD characters several times by
the end of S3. Glassman, Andrews, Lim, Debbie, Lea… even residents like Shaun
(when he was briefly moved to Pathology in S2) and Park—well, offscreen anyway,
before we met him.
We now know that Morgan has chosen internal medicine as her
new specialty, and in doing so gets plenty of crossover between Morgan’s
patients and the surgical staff… and just enough time doing so to aggravate her,
her former colleagues, or both. Good choice, TGD writers Morgan!
You‘ve probably noticed, as have I, that Claire’s personal
life (and personal ambition, for that matter) have been on the back burner
since she spent half the TGD pandemic searching for Deeper Meaning with
Ghost Melendez. We were treated to that one brief scene of Claire and Lim
duking it out video-game style, and it’d make sense for Claire to factor
significantly in the Lim-centric episode coming January 11 (by “significantly”
I mean she’s more likely to get a scene or two than others in TGD cast). But
making her way from grief to that “amazing career” promised by Ghost Melendez
has yet to be seen. Now that the Newbies have been established, I think
Claire’s time to be tested is coming soon. With Morgan finding new and
interesting ways to breathe down her neck from afar, of course!
In the meantime, Morgan seems to have plenty of time to play
practical jokes on Park…
Well, I guess they weren’t all practical jokes. One
time she hid all the large-size surgical scrubs (31 sets!) to see Park forced
to come to the O.R. looking like he’d just been for a ride in some sort of
surgeon’s clown car; another, she changed the ring tone on his phone to
“Margaritaville” without telling him, which prompted some embarrassment at the nurses' station. But she also went out of her way to chase
him down in the parking garage and hit him with questions until he reluctantly
shared the news about his brand-new divorce…which led to Park and Morgan now
doing the roommate thang.
So where’s that going to go, and how long will it take to get there? That remains to be seen, but anyone who thought Park and Morgan were hooking up pre “Winter Finale” came away disappointed. Or maybe more like… relieved?
I guess it depends on your enthusiasm for the Park/Morgan possibility. Personally, I support it. I don’t think they’re destined for long-term coupledom, but aside from that I don’t have any specific expectations so I’ll welcome whatever TGD writers want to send our way. The rivalry they shared last season was fun; now that they’re not in direct competition with each other—and now that Park’s made his divorce final—the options seem wide open. The “bonding over failed relationships” thing they did throughout “Fault” was a lot more fun than I anticipated… I think that’s because I figured they’d get a little more serious about the subject at hand a little sooner. But the investigative back-and-forth was a fun way to learn more about the two characters, particularly Morgan. And the trash can fire-of-mourning ceremony—which not only honored what they’re moving away from, but celebrated their respective baby steps towards moving forward (Bumble, “swiping right”)—took them to a new level. Color me intrigued!
One more thing about Park while I’m thinking about it… of the four “veteran” residents, I believe he’s the only one we have yet to see leading a surgery. (Remember that he got called away during Shaun’s initial attempt at a lead surgery… while Shaun ultimately had to forfeit that one, Park successfully led his first offscreen.) So I hope the show finds a way to work a Park-led scenario this season—given that both Lim and Andrews seem to have a lot of faith in him, it’d be interesting to see that faith challenged by Park and/or whatever Newbie he might be supervising at the time.
Speaking of Andrews, and Newbies… pretty savvy of TGD to give newbie Olivia a familial connection to Andrews. When word went around that a character from the show wasn’t going to survive last season’s earthquake, I initially thought of Andrews (until it became clear he wasn’t anywhere near the brewpub rescue efforts) because he seemed like a doctor with little on his emotional plate once he acclimated to his demotion. With “Livvy” as his niece, however, Andrews has some real skin in the game of Survivor: Newbies Edition. What’s more, it puts him on a compatible level of sorts with Glassman. The situations aren’t quite the same of course, given Shaun has ASD and Olivia doesn’t. But the nepotism involving the latter is real, so I hope it leads to—among other things—some hard-hitting scenes with Glassman and Andrews like we probably haven’t seen since S1.
Which brings us to Dr. Audrey Lim, current chief of surgery
and the one whose romantic relationship with the late Dr. Melendez has been
overshadowed by the Melendaire fallout… until now. “Lim” (4.6), the
episode promised to us when TGD returns on January 11, is exciting to me
because she’s a character who, like Lea, came into the show with more
dimensions than a show like this can handle on the regular:
*
She came in midway through S1(recurring, like
Lea before her and Morgan after her), so her introduction was somewhat
truncated
*
Her strength, confidence, and independence shone
through when she was revealed (in 2.3 “36 Hours) to be a motorcycle enthusiast
willing to make enough ruckus over a traffic ticket to be jailed in contempt of
court
*
Her gentle side has been underscored not only in
some of her dealings with Shaun, but in that weird little subplot of 3.16 “Autopsy”
that had Lim chasing down an 8 year-old wandering around St. B while her mom
was hospitalized.
*
At various times in the series she’s had
historical touchpoints with Glassman, Melendez, and most recently with Nurse
Patringa (R.I.P.)
*
And of course when she was the doctor
down for the count in season 2’s “Quarantine” 2-parter, it kicked her romantic
entanglement with Melendez into high gear. Although she broke up with him in S3’s
“Moonshot” episode, most of her personal aftermath was unseen until Melendez’s earthquake
injuries sealed his fate.
What’s become of Lim since then? We know she had the park bench ritual going with Claire until the latter declared (after a considerable amount of time spent with Ghost Melendez) she was ready to move on. We know Lim was as gutted by the pandemic as any doctor on the show—moreso, maybe, as chief of surgery—but we don’t know much about how she dealt with that so soon after Melendez’s death. We know she currently “likes to fill her evenings with numbing mindlessness” as per her response to Claire about why she’s so good at video games. (Oh, and if we’re to deduce anything from her on-screen video game persona… her middle name starts with an X. At least, that’s how it translates from Chinese.)
And finally, we have those moments during the climactic
scene in “Fault” that found Lim hearing nothing but the flatline for a few
moments… while the intensity mounted for Dr. Wolke and others in the O.R. I’ve
got to presume this will be explained, in some manner, next episode—perhaps even
re-visiting this scene from Lim’s perspective.
I’ve heard some associate Lim’s “flatline moment” with
Melendez’s death, and I suppose that could be on target. My own guess, though,
is that if her former flame turns up in “Lim” it will be in unseen-before flashbacks.
They already did present-day Neil, so to speak… why repeat it? In Lim’s case, I
suspect it’ll be more valuable to see Limlendez in earlier incarnations—residents
days, as a couple, as a broken-up couple trying again to be colleagues. I can
also see the Lim-centric episode perhaps taking us to parts of her life we
haven’t seen up close yet, such as her family of origin and her personal
struggles as a woman of color (something over which she’s bonded with Claire)
rising to the top in a male-dominated industry.
So many options for this one! I’d better stop there before I
get myself disappointed with what doesn’t make the cut on this next
episode.
How do YOU feel about developments with the veteran TGD characters
so far this season? Share your thoughts in the comments!
6 comments:
I never thought Morgan was leaving the show, but I thought she'd push herself until she made a colossal mistake in surgery and that would be when she got busted for hiding her rheumatoid arthritis diagnosis, so I was impressed and considered it major growth on her part that she 'fessed up on her own to Lim. I wasn't surprised when she changed her mind about the synovectomy either, and when she took it upon herself to do surgery on the ectopic pregnancy patient while all the other surgeons were busy in the aftermath of the earthquake, although she did go looking for another surgeon, and when she cringed, I figured she was seeing Andrews at work there and thought, "No, I'm not asking him," and I admit, both the cringing at the thought of approaching Andrews, and doing the surgery herself, are both things I would have done in her place. I'm sorry she doesn't get to be a surgeon anymore, but I'm thrilled that she's still a major part of things, and I predict more Armchair Surgeon-ing on her part for the remainder of the season.
Honestly, I'm pretty much done with Claire as a character. Her love life has always been a trainwreck--she couldn't return Jared's love and didn't even appreciate that he nearly sacrificed his career to defend her honor in S1; she wasn't open to her friend's widower; she glommed on to Melendez without any thought to the consequences of their relationship in the #MeToo era after Melendez and Lim had enough problems with HR when they were equals in status at work, both still attendings. Her downward spiral after her mother's death made sense, but as good a friend as Morgan was to her after that, accompanying her to scatter her mother's ashes, covering for her while she was on her binge of drinking and one-night stands, and having the guts to tell her when she found her in that bar, "Stop doing this before this is who you really become," Claire most certainly is not returning the favor now, so I'm forced to view the Morgan/Claire friendship as one-sided, on Morgan's side. She cared enough to do her part to stop Claire from self-destructing, and Claire is, from my point of view, too self-involved to even express any sympathy for Morgan's career turn, because while Park chose to stop being a cop and become a surgeon, Morgan had to give up her dream of being a surgeon to become an internist, and she shared with Nurse Petringa that she really doesn't like being an internist. And Claire really slacked off because of all the time she spent obsessing over those dog tags and seeing/speaking to Ghost Melendez in "Frontline Pt. 2" compared to all the other doctors. Glassman had a medical reason not to be there and be involved; everyone else sacrificed and struggled, but Claire basically had one patient she was affected by in "Frontline Pt. 1" and then it was her talking to Ghost Melendez and spending all her time finding the person to give those dog tags to. Claire could do better, but I'm not holding my breath that she will. Not anymore.
Lim has really been through the wringer, and Melendez's death followed so closely by Petringa's death AND losing all those patients to COVID...I was with Lim with the woman in the elevator, and I'm not usually that outspoken, but I could definitely be pushed to the point where I'd do as Lim did the third time they were on the elevator together and just tell the woman, "Wear your damn mask!" She has shown great growth, and great strength in being able to bear all of these stresses and losses one after another while being the best Chief of Surgery St. Bonaventure has ever had. I'm looking forward to her spotlight episode in January, and I hope she's able to find some peace of mind in the second half of the season.
I prefer Park and Morgan as friends and platonic roommates. Morgan can be a terrific friend. I wish we'd get some Morgan/Shaun and/or Morgan/Lea interaction, because Morgan has proved to be an excellent friend to Shaun, and she was a better friend that Claire ended up deserving, and now is the time for Morgan's friendship with Park to blossom. I'd also like to see more of Park and Kellan. Maybe Kellan is at San Jose State University, or another college nearby, and can spend more time with his dad. Park has a lot to offer both professionally and personally, and I look forward to his continuing journey.
I made the same parallel you did between Andrews/Olivia and Glassman/Shaun, Kelli, except, of course, that Olivia doesn't have ASD. I wouldn't mind seeing Glassman and Andrews cross swords over the nepotism aspect of Olivia's internship. One stark difference between Glassman and Andrews, however: Glassman left it up to Shaun to prove himself, because he knew that was what it would take. He knew that Shaun would have to step up and deliver in the OR and with the patients on his own, without Glassman holding his hand or coaching him, and Shaun continues to do that. Andrews wanted to grease the wheels for Olivia, and she finally had to tell him that she has to do this on her own. I find it fascinating that Glassman staked his job on Shaun's abilities as a doctor, a surgeon, but Andrews was trying to make internship a plum assignment for Olivia when it's anything but a plum assignment. Kudos to Olivia for telling her well-meaning uncle that she has to do this on her own. Even Glassman had to back off of Shaun in S1, although that was more about communication than medical skill or Shaun's job.
Thank you, Kelli, for getting the other major characters into the spotlight. There have been major shifts in the professional and private lives of so many on TGD within the last year and I’m quite pleased that obviously Lim is at last getting a spotlight episode. The character’s strong personality, its way in a male-dominated work environment and its costs are worthwhile to be explored more.
I’ve no doubt that Melendez will be a factor in episode 406 again, yet I hope that her latest lover will be only one facet among many that make the Chief’s steely exterior crack and reveal a little more of the true Lim. I just want to stress that the break-up with Melendez and his death is not the only punches Lim had to take since she took the new position. For example, she decided against Max donating a kidney to his mentor Wes in 317 “Fixation”, sealing Wes’ fate in doing so. Lim felt unsecure about being Chief from the beginning. Self-doubt and forced isolation from her former colleagues might be factors to be considered here, too.
Lim dealing with her issues might give Claire something to do again for an episode, although in a supporting role only. Her character needed a break from all the crisis that plagued Claire in season 3, but Ghost Melendez promising her “an amazing story ahead” made me fear for the worst: the character becoming boring! Because in a drama series, a character that never struggles but only excels becomes irrelevant to the unfolding drama.
Season 3 went down the entire road to deconstruct the image of “Saint Claire”, the ever understanding, empathetic role model. We saw Claire battle against the past; against her dark side, against her inability to trust and commit to love; against her bad judgement. And she lost it all – mostly by her own poor choices.
At this point, any character has the chance to be “reborn” as a better version of itself. But with Claire, there is no indication that she has learned the lessons life threw at her. She manages the newbies effortless and rules the OR, but still rejects Morgan’s friendship and appears to be totally self-absorbed since her quest for the dog tags. She might be over Melendez, but where is her personality heading? Her character arc feels like it has reached its destination and still unfinished. Almost as if the writers have lost interest in pursuing any meaningful story for Claire – and after all the harassment they had to endure I wouldn’t blame them…
At the same time, much effort is put into Morgan’s stories – and it is delightful to see the character wrestling with fate and their own choices, while still finding the energy to fight for the patients’ best care either way and getting under the skin of colleagues Morgan cares for – in her very unique Morgan-bitch-style. I would argue that Morgan has developed into a much more interesting and versatile female lead character than touchy Saint Claire, who clearly lacks Morgan’s esprit.
I agree with your assessments of Claire and of Morgan, Andreas. They put Claire through the wringer in S3, but instead of working on building her back better in S4, so far anyway, she's kind of stalled out personally. I don't particularly care to see her in a serious romantic relationship with anyone, but Claire is still blowing up her personal life by rebuffing Morgan's friendship and, so far anyway, really only interacting with Lim in a positive manner outside of work, with the video games. Claire definitely lacks Morgan's esprit. And while Morgan's family issues are different from Claire's, she has still managed to rise above a devastating combination of being the black sheep in her family because she's a doctor and they are all artists AND losing her surgical career and having to become an internist. She's still learning and growing both professionally and personally. We can no longer say the same about Claire.
Thank you Kelli. Like Amy and Andreas, I am grateful for the opportunity to discuss the supporting characters, too. Especially Dr. Lim.
I'm always impressed by her natural leadership, self assuredness, and loyalty towards others. But, recently it's been very interesting to see those aspects of her character being tested and I can barely wait to see what the next episode brings. As Andreas said, this new episode might even present an opportunity for Claire to shine as a good friend to her too.
On a side note, after everything that's happened to Claire, I can actually understand why she's now gravitating towards a maternal figure like Lim instead of a sibling rival like Morgan. For one, Lim offers her a nurturing AND less contentious relationship which may be like a salve following her broken heart. And two, Morgan is having way too much fun with the games that she's playing AND using to cope with her professional losses. Which should ultimately prove to be a step in the right direction for Morgan, even if it's not currently IN step with Claire right now.
Also, Morgan has an entertaining yet intrusive way of showing that she cares. So, perhaps it's better that she's paired for the moment with the far more reserved Park for her character development... and his. I mean who better to peel that onion by unabashedly going through his underwear drawer than Morgan.
No doubt, Morgan and Park are going to learn a lot from each other and may even get real friendly in the process. But, I can't help but notice that Morgan plays different - often amusing - games with Park. The games she plays with Claire, however, really do undermine her professional authority. Which would put anyone on edge, I'd think.
So, just to reiterate, I can see how drifting closer to Lim vs Morgan is a good choice for Claire at the moment. This may not be as exciting as what they're having Morgan do right now, but I do believe that this is evidence of Claire's growth. Truth be told, she's no longer seeking out one night stands as a means to combat grief. Instead she's spending evenings laying the groundwork for a friendship with someone who will most certainly respect her in the morning... Which is a phrase ordinarily reserved for romantic liaisons, but I think it might also apply to her friendship with Morgan too. After all, Morgan has not been giving Claire's much R.E.S.P.E.C.T. these days.
Also, as others have mentioned, I wouldn't be surprised if Lim is dealing with PTSD. I was particularly struck by her shell shocked reaction at the end of "Fault," which was underscored, as Kelli mentioned, by that deafening tone of a flat lining monitor. In my opinion, the sound of a flatline was poignantly utilized, almost as if it were an allusion to tinnitus - that telltale ringing of the ear that some veterans of war experience.
Additionally, recent events with Wolke's patient reminded me of Lim's conversations with Han way back in season 2. Back then, Dr. Han expressed his skepticism of Shaun and openly questioned his ability to one day supervise residents. And now, nearly 2 years later, I wonder if Lim will begin to ask herself if Han was right. Or if it will simply reinforce what she has always believed: that everyone makes mistakes and that everyone can learn. Even veteran surgeons like herself.
P.S. I'm sorry if it sounds like I'm a Claire apologist. The truth is that I probably am. I can't seem to help it, though. When it comes to personal and professional motivations, Claire and I are virtually the same person with some of the same faults. Needless to say, I wouldn't mind seeing where she goes from here.
Wonderful insights, Angelica! Thanks for sharing them!
Post a Comment