WHAT THE HELL JUST HAPPENED
^^^That was the first thing I tweeted upon seeing that post-"Parenting” promo Monday night-- a promo that had remained a mystery until that moment, as TGD had not yet even supplied a title for the next episode yet, never mind a synopsis (As I write this, they still haven’t-- perhaps taking full advantage of the fact that said episode won’t air until mid-February.)
You may have tweeted things too. Lots, and lots, and LOTS of things. Or ranted in a TGD group on Facebook. Or just stared at your TV, long after the late news started on your local ABC affiliate, the words just forming over your head in a silent cartoon bubble: What was… who was that… I’m sorry, Shaun’s crushing on…? WHY IS HE ALMOST KISSING ANOTHER…?!?!?!
I’ll put it another way: During the course of Monday’s “Parenting” episode, I received 17 notifications on Twitter that were related to the episode (not including multiple RTs and Likes).
Since 10:59 E.S.T. on Monday-- when that promo made its debut-- Those notifications for me on Twitter shot up to well over 100. JUST about the promo. And also not including multiple RTs and Likes.
Plus, several eager-to-vent readers made use of the comments section of my previous post. (You don’t have to be as succinct there as you do on Twitter.)
Which is why… much as you and I want to talk about the NEARLY 12 MINUTES of #Shea content in “Parenting” (including Shaun’s hotel lobby scene and the Lea/Glassman exchange)... I’m posting about that damn promo that many #Shea fans are taking very, very personally.
(But I’m not SHOWING said promo here because I’m not into torture. You’re welcome!)
In order to actually get something out to you a little sooner than usual, I’ve decided to bring y’all in and employ a sampling of those comments/notifications I’ve read thus far. There were too many to seek permission to use this time, so I’m posting them without attribution. Maybe you’ll see your words here; maybe you’ll see words that match your thoughts completely…
That was uncalled for. I’m just hoping that looks worse than it is…
It is totally disastrous that after this episode they give us one like that, it would be better if nothing happens because it is very unfair. Also, Shaun is not that kind of guy.
What was that shit?
Lea could’ve used this humble pie in season 2 but not now. Too bad they just didn’t let us enjoy this episode.
I honestly didn't like the promo at all, it gave me a heart attack. But I trust Shaun and Lea's relationship.
Here I was thinking the next phase for Shea was going to be marriage and starting a family… now I’ve got to deal with him breaking Lea’s heart. I can’t wait 3 weeks.
I will be disappointed if they break them up.
I’m sorry but wtf are they planning to do???? Make Shaun a cheater suddenly in 1 episode???? After a beautiful episode like tonight where Shaun fought to hard to gain Lea’s parents because of her... it’s just not who Shaun is...
Breaking her heart just seems too much for me. We don’t need this after the bummer coronavirus year we went through.
Shore punched me in the face at 10:59 pm.
Remember when Shaun started dating Carly, and without any care towards Lea’s feelings he told her she had to move out. I don’t think Shaun thinks of Lea’s feelings... he doesn’t have empathy.
(I vocalized my objection to that last part of the statement right away, FWIW.)
So he might not realize his actions (i.e., he tells Lea he is attracted to someone else because he is honest) could be breaking her heart..
What if this new woman doctor is kind of like a sleaze and wants Shaun just for sex. Or wants to take advantage of him somehow?
I’m willing to be positive but then I can’t help to wonder why they ( producers/writers) would use that storyline and promo... it only make fans anxious.
That last one tagged me a few days later, which is also when ABC put the promo onTwitter (and, in turn, numerous #Shea fans expressed outrage all over again). I’ll show you my response to that Tweet later, but first, here are some of the longer-form reactions that turned up in my “Comments” section…
From Faghost: CAN WE TALK ABOUT THE PROMO FOR 4x09, PLEASE????! I mean, Andreas and I, and I hope other bunch of us Shea fans, kinda agree that a little bit of jealousy will do Lea and her relationship with Shaun good. Also, especially Shaun will get the chance to learn more about life, specifically lust and love.. but boy the cowbell really has me nervous. That and we're approaching 10... still so many episodes remain and lots of possibilities will happen down the line.
From Andreas, who compares the theme of the promo to the Greek mythological tale of Calypso and Odysseus: The latest episodes appear to lean heavily on revisiting themes already played in the previous season and jealousy was a big one in season 3 as all on team Shea probably remember vividly. Now, recall what Morgan had to say about it: “It's flattering, stimulating, it means you're committed, and you care. […] like all things, a little is good, and a lot will kill you. My advice: Admit you're jealous, give in to it, and then get over it.”
What Morgan was trying to say to Carly was that working through the jealousy would provide a new perspective to the relationship, enforcing the pros and cons and - if overcome – might strengthen the relationship because the couple knows better why it matters.
Lea has issues with commitment and self-esteem, we all hope and long for the show to address that specifically.
From Tony Payne: The "next episode" promo was just that - an ABC promo designed to get a rise out of people and spark discussion. I've seen some people get VERY worried (almost irrationally so), and I truly feel that ABC got its intended effect and then some! I don't believe for a second that the show's going to have its main protagonist give into temptation, lest he lose the sympathy and support from such a huge portion of the audience. This is not DEFCON-1; this is not a Doomsday siren. Even so, it'll be interesting to see just how it DOES play out on February 15.
From Mary: I agree with Tony. The promo for the next episode aims to spark discussion and create a strong suspense in these two weeks off. I don't think Shaun will kiss the new radiologist, it's just his imagination, because he says "I am having thoughts I don't want to have". He has always been honest, so he will tell Lea how he feels and that will surely hurt her. This makes me think of Glassman's words "It's rarely intentional" that he addresses to Lea, but, out of all expectations, Shaun will hurt Lea. In my opinion, moreover, this dynamic will serve to counter Lea's haters who say that sooner or later she will hurt Shaun, without thinking that it could be the opposite, as it seems to be in fact. Anyway, I'm sure Shaun and Lea will overcome this challenge too.
And from Vale (co-creator of the “Shea: Endgame” IG account: My question is, yeah Shaun will be honest but how do you think that Lea will handle this situation, how are they going to overcome this? Because to know that your partner is having thoughts with another woman, even if he doesn't act upon them, hurts and it will hurt Lea's self-esteem even more. You don't feel good enough, you feel like he has to be looking out for something you can't give him bla-bla-bla. So, how? How you move on after such a painful declaration?
I'm leaning to the whole almost kiss as a daydreaming or thought from Shaun, the whole situation is so unlike him, he is sitting so close to a person he barely knows and he is allowing her to touch him. Seems like a product of someone's else imagination to be honest.
The lack of physical content between Shaun and Lea is killing me, sincerely I miss their interactions to be sweeter and loving beyond words.
We all blame pandemic protocol, heightened perhaps by the fact that Richard Schiff (Glassman) had just been hospitalized for COVID in real life around the time these episodes were shot… but maybe that made the promo all the more upsetting for us. Why do we have to see him having and/or acting on feelings of attraction for another woman when we can’t even see him lay a finger on the woman he loves?
WHY GO DOWN THIS ROAD AT ALL? Some may still be wondering.
I say “still” because I know, for some, the visceral reaction they had at first sight of the promo on Monday night has subsided somewhat. But if you still need to be talked down from the proverbial ledge, take heart. You’re not alone. And you’re among like-minded friends here. Take a breath, and then read on.
THEORIES… WE’VE GOT THEORIES
As with the previous time TGD jerked our chain with the revelation that Lea has an ex-husband, there are several theories out there as to Shaun’s POTENTIAL (trying to emphasize that word as much as possible) betrayal of his relationship with Lea. A few of them:
He was dreaming it (evidenced by his line “I’m having thoughts I don’t want to have…”)
He was daydreaming/fantasizing (same evidence as above)
She (the mystery radiologist for whom we now call “SHE” with narrowed, accusing eyes) was putting moves on Shaun that he will ultimately reject in that same scene
He was conducting an experiment, much as he did when he was trying to gauge his feelings for Lea a year ago by way of taking his pulse (as Andreas reminded). Except the stakes this time are a LOT higher.
Lea got her brave on after Shaun confessed his feelings (because he’s Shaun; you know it’s inevitable he’ll do that) and encouraged him to conduct an experiment
One of the other St. B-Vites (Jordan? Park?) encouraged him to conduct an experiment
SHE herself suggested “an experiment”
I’m borrowing from reader Erin on that last one, who still had the promo on her mind 4 days later (don’t we all?):
I’m wondering if anyone else has come to this conclusion about the kiss in the promo. Maybe they are both ‘testing’ to see if the attraction is actually valid? Although I still don’t like the idea of what’s her name touching Shaun....
One thing that’s NOT in that list of theories is the possibility that Shaun is giving in to temptation outright-- we just don’t see it, much as we object strongly to seeing Shaun even entertaining the idea of kissing another woman when his love for Lea is so steadfast.
But maybe that’s the point. Shaun is still getting up to speed with all things love, lust, and relationship-related. He’s clearly confused and upset (“Shouldn’t loving Lea make (the thoughts) go away?”), but that doesn’t change the fact that he’s capable of feeling attraction to someone else-- something WE were expecting about as much as he was.
Another reader mentioned on Twitter that Shaun’s held “the moral high ground” in the relationship up to now, and I get that. He’s the ultimate late bloomer after all-- he’s had a lot less time to make mistakes. And the presumption, stated as recently as this past week with Glassman’s convo with Lea, is that Shaun’s the one most capable of getting hurt in this love relationship. Maybe it’s time to challenge that mindset? (Trying to step into the shoes of a TGD writer here...)
On top of Shaun’s relative “innocence” is the fact that he has a developmental disability that allows him to bring many unique qualities to a romance, not the least of which is for-better-or-worse transparency. Whatever does or doesn’t happen with SHE, we presume he will tell Lea about it. And let’s face it-- Lea likely has him on that moral pedestal herself. He’s not like other guys she’s dated, and to her, that surely means he won’t cheat on her either. She may be right about that, but what about that grey zone where attraction-without-action lies? And (yep, we’re asking it over and over again) how will this impact her self-esteem… the fragile, barely-there kind that might immediately leave her wondering if she’s “enough” for Shaun after all?
In short, if that’s possible at this point in a lengthy post… I think a lot of #Shea shippers are hurting because they feel this deeply from both edges of the sword. We are Shaun, bewildered by this sudden invasion of unwanted thoughts, not realizing such was possible. And we are Lea, unprepared and unsure what this might mean for “us” at this point and time.
Wait- can there be a third edge to this particular “sword”? If so, it’s this: Shaun and Lea already know (wink) what really goes down in TGD 4.9, while WE still have about two weeks of waiting and wondering ahead of us. Poor us!
So in that interim, might I suggest the following:
Skip watching the promo again, no matter how many times it shows up in your social media feeds. Keep it muted and scroll on by. It’ll pass. Literally.
If you insist on watching it, and/or can’t get it out of your mind anyway, remember that U.S. promos for TGD love taking things out of context and out of sequence in order to build a more compelling 30 seconds.
Shaun and Lea’s journey-- all of Season 4, in fact-- is only now getting into the second of three arcs of storytelling (assuming 18-20 episodes in the season with 6-7 episodes per “arc”). In other words, still a long way to go… especially with the COVID episodes pushing plans back a bit.
Whatever happens with all this, I’d bet you a bag of Hershey Kisses (the cherry cordial kind, even!) that #Shea will emerge stronger. As they do with every test thus far.
Get yourself some ice cream or a bucket of wings (or whatever works for you) and meditate, or watch all the #Shea videos on YouTube that you can reasonably make time for, or go for a daily walk with “Send the Rain (to Everyone)” on repeat. Whatever self-care you need to employ during the first two weeks of February, DO IT.
Because... #Shea are going to keep getting tested in one way or another, which means we are too. February, March, April (and maybe beyond?) still await! We’ve got to at least try to toughen up our tender #Shea hearts a bit, don’t you think?
Here’s what I told the viewer who Tweeted I’m willing to be positive but then I can’t help to wonder why they ( producers/writers) would use that storyline and promo... it only make fans anxious…
--
Reasons for the storyline are not as simple as reason for the promo: to give #TheGoodDoctor viewers an extremely memorable reason to stay tuned for new episodes. Suspense (ALL kinds) is a time-honored tradition... wagering our need to know what happens will override any anxiety.
Did the show place its bets correctly? Let me know where you're at with processing THAT DAMN PROMO in the comments.
(We'll talk about "Parenting" in a few days, so come back soon.)